System renewal. Challenging established notions. Reimagining our societies.

On weaponising the fear of others

nbc-fires-donald-trump-after-he-calls-mexicans-rapists-and-drug-runners-2

When, 30 years ago as an idealistic, immigrant graduate student, someone first objected that if I “didn’t like it here [in America], then [I] can just [go] back to England,” I was naïve enough to take it as a challenge and tried to show the error of the argument.

The result was obvious, in hindsight – a prolonged and increasingly animated debate with no positive resolution.  The university where I pursued my graduate study was, by its nature, an environment populated with curious people; however, in those early days, I also had a glimpse of a different side of America.

I have come to learn that the “if you don’t like it here” criticism – which is not uniquely American – is one against which it is impossible to argue. It reflects a mindset that is uncomfortable with differences and that resists change and new ideas. It is often thrown out with the intent of ending discussion in a way that allows no viable rejoinder. It is a trademark of an insecurity that resists critical evaluation of a nation’s flaws. It is akin to walking away from the game and taking your marbles.

This is how President Donald Trump plays. If he doesn’t get his way, he takes his marbles and uses childish epithets to kick everyone else out of the playground. It is symptomatic of his insecurity – a difference of opinion is perceived as a personal insult. That a man like that has become the most powerful in the world has deep – and dark – implications about the state of America today.

President Trump, thin-skinned and childish as he can be, is smart. His agenda is solely the aggrandizement of Donald J. Trump. To fulfil this agenda, he has intuited the power of the fear of uncertainty, difference and change.

He has tapped into a minority, but potent, sentiment (that, to be fair, exists within all nationalities, not just the US – note Brexit, National Rally, Law and Justice, the Northern League…) and he has been masterful in its exploitation. He has weaponised fear of the unfamiliar.

Contrary to much of the impassioned responses to the now-infamous July 14 tweets, my experience is that this language is not inherently racist. The way Trump used it may be racist, but, as a white male, I have received the same directive. That Mr Trump’s directed his invective at four women of colour, illustrates his guile. It simultaneously taps into the tensions of race relations, women’s rights, and religious intolerance that exist in America today, while exploiting the fear by “us” of “them”.

By focusing on whether or not Mr Trump is racist, the opposition has played into his hand; the new immigration order has gone virtually unquestioned; Mr Trump has been able to paint his opponents as radicals, who focus on identity issues; and he has avoided his biggest weakness – the inability to discuss ideas.

After 30 years living in the US, I clearly have not returned to England as I had been encouraged. Instead, I have embraced America, with all its flaws. America is a great country whose legacy is built on acknowledging its flaws and problems and then doing something about them. The maxim “nations do behave wisely once they have exhausted all other alternatives” (often, incorrectly, attributed to Sir Winston Churchill) holds hope that America – and the rest of the world that is toying with populism – will ultimately do the right thing.

America will eventually confine Donald Trump’s inflammatory style to the dustbin of history; it will recognize its 21st Century challenges; and it will ultimately do the right thing again. That is the power of ideas.

Rate this post!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

Radix is the radical centre think tank. We welcome all contributions which promote system change, challenge established notions and re-imagine our societies. The views expressed here are those of the individual contributor and not necessarily shared by Radix.

Comments

  1. Stephen Gwynne says

    I find it intriguing that this whole post rejects difference and infact seeks to undermine diversity by trying to delegitimise the opposition as infantile.

    The question of diversity and diversity of viewpoints is now centre stage in the struggle between so called left and right policies with each condemning the other when they don’t get there own way.

    Of course, you are entitled to your opinion and your attempts to reinforce manufactured consent of the left and manufactured dissent of the right but visceral partisanship is currently part and parcel of democratic debate.

    Different policies appeal to different demagraphics for very different reasons and one of the main dichotomies that seem to underlie the current partisanship is the difference between cosmopolitanism and communitarianism. These broad policy frameworks then tap into questions regarding borders, trade, the composition of national demagraphics and how best to create national social, cultural, economic, political and ecological security in the face of a rapidly growing human population, climatic, environmental and ecological disruptions, growing resource scarcity and the rising costs of surplus energy.

    Evoking rhetoric that simply denounces one or the other is not reason based debate, it is simply one side complaining about the other without providing substantive arguments about the real issues that are affecting people’s day to day lives.

    It is one thing to simply proffer emotions as the basis of our choices, it is another to articulate reasoned arguments that can without doubt validate why we think we are right and why we think our political opponents are wrong. Emotional rhetoric about the weaponisation of fear is one thing, providing informed research as to why we think our policy objectives are the best is another.

    Your experiences would be made that much clearer if you could cite what you said to invoke the response “if I didn’t like it here [in America], then [I] can just [go] back to England”.

    I’ve heard plenty of non-British citizens complain about Britain which when pressed was because their expectations of a great job, a great house and a great wage wasn’t being met. In other words, they came here because they saw Britain as the land of wealth and opportunity, but when those opportunities didn’t materialise, then they would seek out convenient scapegoats, which are readily provided by the Left. This I call capitalising on disenchantment or in your terms of reference, weaponising disenchantment and unfulfilled expectations.

Leave a Reply

The Author
Latest Related Work
Follow Us
[type='radio']
[type='radio']
[type='checkbox']
[type='checkbox']
[type='submit']
[type='submit']
[type='button']
[type='button']
[type='image']
[type='image']
[type='file']
[type='file']
[gravityform id=4 title=false description=false ajax=true tabindex=87]
  • RSVP

  • We will process your data in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You may withdraw this consent at any time by emailing us.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
[type='radio']
[type='radio']
[type='checkbox']
[type='checkbox']
[type='submit']
[type='submit']
[type='button']
[type='button']
[type='image']
[type='image']
[type='file']
[type='file']
[gravityform id=2 title=false description=false ajax=true tabindex=69]
  • Join Our Movement

    Keep updated on what's going on. Get email notifications

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
[type='radio']
[type='radio']
[type='checkbox']
[type='checkbox']
[type='submit']
[type='submit']
[type='button']
[type='button']
[type='image']
[type='image']
[type='file']
[type='file']
[gravityform id=5 title=false description=false ajax=true tabindex=64]
  • Get emails

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
[type='radio']
[type='radio']
[type='checkbox']
[type='checkbox']
[type='submit']
[type='submit']
[type='button']
[type='button']
[type='image']
[type='image']
[type='file']
[type='file']
[gravityform id=6 title=false description=false ajax=true tabindex=999]
  • Before you go!

    Stay up to date with what's happening at Radix. Get email notifications

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.